When I was 13, I wrote a poem in English class wherein I posed a question about death. At the time, I didn’t think too much of it, but once my teacher read it, I was immediately sent to the school guidance counselor. I still remember the way she looked at me, her huge grey eyes magnified behind her glasses, almost comically wide and unblinking. She kept leaning toward me, much too close, repeatedly telling me in a stern voice how “concerned” she was, how “disturbing” it was that I had written what I had. It started to feel hard to breathe, and I thought I might throw up. I understand now that she and my teacher were probably just following a school protocol that was meant to help students who they deemed might be in peril, but at the time, it just felt like I was in trouble. The longer I sat there in that suffocating, fluorescently-lit office, the worse I felt; as though I had done something wrong, something shameful; as though I *myself* was wrong, broken. Essentially, this was the first time I remember really feeling I was being given the message that it wasn’t “okay” to “not be okay”. And from then on, I learned to keep any sort of “dark” thoughts or feelings I had largely to myself. I didn’t want to be able to be that outwardly identifiable as being broken again.
I’ve dealt with depression for most of my life now, and ever since that day in the guidance counselor’s office, I’ve noticed this same pattern in the way our society so often seems to handle things like this: we are given the message that “unhappy” thoughts or feelings are “bad”, and if we’re feeling this way, there’s something wrong with us, and we need to be “fixed”. But life is not that simple—or that happy all the time—and I find this view, at best, to be unrealistic; and at worst, problematic. Because look at how life can be sometimes; look at society, look at the world! Darkness exists, and pretending it shouldn’t or trying to push it away only makes it fester, gnawing and growing, until one day, it may run the risk of swallowing us or blotting us out completely.
I was 19 when I was first diagnosed with cancer, and especially at first, I encountered similar attitudes to what I had experienced years earlier in that guidance counselor’s office, but this time in the sterile rooms of the hospital I suddenly found myself in. As I started inpatient treatment, I was visited by social workers, whose wide, largely unblinking eyes and eager leaning-in to my space felt all too familiar. I was constantly encouraged to create art, do crafts, to “embrace” the whole experience with a sunny disposition. And while there is something to be said for trying to find the positives in difficult situations, most of the time I felt so sick that it was all I could do to just make it through each day, much less do it with a smile all the time. I know (and appreciate now) that they were just doing their job and trying to help. But still, I remember having similar feelings of shame to how I felt back in the fateful aftermath of my 7th grade poem. Part of this probably stems from some of my own expectations and judgements, but I remember feeling bad about myself for not being able to be like the “inspirational cancer patients” you always seem to hear about in movies or on the news. Why couldn’t I just muster up the strength to be the sort of person who “is always in a good mood, no matter what”, or who starts some grand jubilant charity or movement out of my adversity?
Still, I was able to find some moments of joy and levity even throughout the ordeal, and at the end of treatment, I was thankfully declared in remission. I started college the following fall, and I thought, going into it, that life would somehow be even better and more colorful than before. You often hear stories about people going through cancer treatment and having some sort of epiphany; they go through this hard experience, but because of it, they emerge stronger, even more grateful for every flower they smell, every note of music they hear, every sunset they see. Maybe it’s like this for some people right away, but for me, at least after that first time having cancer, this wasn’t my experience. In some ways, things sometimes actually felt even harder once treatment was over. Because unlike in the hospital, where much of what I was going through was more normalized on a regular basis, I was now thrust into an environment where most people I was around didn’t understand what I’d gone through—and what I was still, in many ways, continuing to deal with in lingering after-effects, both seen and unseen.
At some points post-treatment, I felt almost more depressed than ever before. Sometimes, things felt so dark, that I felt like it would be easier if I could just be dead. I even remember sometimes wishing that I could’ve traded outcomes with some of the other kids in the hospital who didn’t make it, because I felt like they deserved to live more than I did. But then I would feel EXTREMELY guilty for feeling this way. After all, a team of people had worked so hard to keep me alive—and now here I was, wishing I wasn’t. I felt awful about it, and I felt awful about myself. What was wrong with me? I mean, I was alive; I’d been given a “second chance”; so why couldn’t I just buck up and be happy? It didn’t seem like it should be so hard, but for some reason, I just couldn’t seem to pull myself out of these muddy depths of despair.
Eventually—and especially after college—my mental health did get significantly better overall. I still continued to deal with depression flaring up off and on, but generally, I became a lot better at managing it. And a big part of this is because, somewhere along the way, instead of trying to fight it off, I decided to not only embrace depression and the darker facets of existence, but to also shamelessly claim and proclaim it as one of my truths—as one of *life’s* truths. Because, after all, life is messy—the world is messy—and darkness and light and everything in between are all part of life and living and being human.
After being in remission for almost 8 years, my cancer returned at age 27, and I’ve been in treatment for it since. And during this second treatment, I’ve still encountered similar attitudes regarding mental health: the messaging that I need to “just stay positive” all the time; the befuddled looks or responses I get at times when I’ve expressed that I’m not doing or feeling well; the expectation that because my treatment is working, “everything should all be fine!”
As cancer patients, many of us are familiar with those mental health screening questionnaires—the ones that ask you to identify, on a scale, how many times during the past week you’ve “thought about death or dying”, “felt hopeless”, etc. When I first started filling those out, I made the mistake of being honest and saying that, yes, I had in fact thought about those things quite a bit! My reasoning was, how can you be alive and be human and *not* think about those sorts of things or have those feelings from time to time? It doesn’t mean I’m suicidal, or that I’m going to act on any of it. But especially going through something as hard as cancer treatment, how can you *not* feel at least a little hopeless at times? How can you face something that big, and *not* think about death? I’ve tried explaining this to some providers, and they kind of got it—but still, I’ve learned that the healthcare system overall is not set up for particularly nuanced ways of thinking.
But throughout this experience, I have grown stronger in myself, and I now feel more power to reframe and reclaim things. The system may slap all sorts of labels on me—“depressive disorder”, “anxiety disorder”, etc. But now, instead of feeling put-down by these labels or reactions, or feeling ashamed or like there’s something wrong with me, I am able to step back and confidently say that it is not *me* who is “disordered” or broken or wrong; but rather, it is the system. It is the situation. It is the messy, tangled nature of life itself. The way I see it, I am having a very reasonable, human reaction to these hard things. And ironically, now that I’ve learned to more fully and confidently embrace these darker aspects of life and ways of feeling, I actually feel much lighter overall.
Every now and then, however, I do still have those moments of feeling like I want to die. But I no longer feel guilty about having these feelings. Instead, I feel grateful. Because yes, people have worked hard to keep me alive so I can continue onward and have a full life, and isn’t that the whole point? Human existence encompasses a whole breadth of emotions and feelings, and here I am, fully experiencing and fully LIVING throughout the vast spectrum of everything that existence entails. Here I am, experiencing the euphoria of mountaintops and starshine, the swell of songs you wish would never end; the crashing of tumultuous waves as they drag you down to their brackish abyss; the crescendo of the storm as it calms and the settling of the sea as it sparkles once again; the highs, the lows, the dark, the light, and everything in between. And what an absolute gift to be able to live and experience it—ALL of it.
So we need to normalize that it’s okay to not always feel “okay”—in all aspects of life. There still needs to be proper vigilance and support, yes; but as a society, we also need to recognize the very human nature from which these “darker” feelings stem, and not act like there’s anything wrong or shameful or taboo about having them. This way, maybe more people can be less afraid of being judged for being honest about how they feel, and maybe more people will be more apt to not only seek help when they need it, but also to help themselves through more thoroughly being able to accept and embrace their full humanity. And the sooner we can do this, perhaps the sooner more of us can live—and *keep* living—more fully.
Join the Conversation!
Leave a comment below. Remember to keep it positive!