I spent most of my life before cancer on the outside. I was an observer rather than a participant. Much of that was the severe anxiety I was drowning in, but that’s not all of it. All of the things I enjoy most could be easily considered documenting. I’m a writer. I’m a photographer. I am even something of a musician. I never felt that I should have an active role in what I was documenting, and I felt better suited to my quiet observations. I have literally made my living through my observation. Before cancer I was happy with this lot that I had simultaneously been thrown into and chosen. The problem is that my first cancer diagnosis rocked this view of myself; I didn’t want to just observe anymore, and then I fell in love, and then I got my heart broken.
Alfred, Lord Tennyson wrote in In Memoriam A.H.H., “‘Tis better to have loved and lost than never to have loved at all.” This might usually be true but timing still feels important. When I fell in love I was clear from cancer and was trying to move on with my life. I was not actively seeking love. I was actively trying to avoid it because I planned on leaving the country within the next year. I don’t know what it was that had led me to reach out to a woman I had briefly known several years prior—there certainly wasn’t enough there to warrant this being an old friend reaching out, but I did anyway and she was receptive. There was an immediate connection and we talked constantly until I finally met up with her to see Orville Peck. She told me she was a lesbian, and I was just happy to have a new friend so I didn’t try to pursue her romantically.
We went to see a friend of mine play a gig not long after the Orville show and everyone around us knew there was something there. She might have as well—I did not. I still just thought I had a new friend. We did go on our first official date the next weekend, however. She asked me out.
The beginning of this relationship was incredible. I was happy, everything was new and exciting, and we were enjoying each other’s company. I had forgotten about cancer.
What led to her dumping me was her mental health. She was experiencing an existential crisis and speaking to her therapist on the phone daily. I was doing my best to be a supportive partner. I was no stranger to crises, both existential and mortal. She was abysmal in a crisis. We went out one evening and I had to stop by the hospital to pick up oral contrast for my upcoming scan and she told me that she could not walk into the hospital with me because her parents had tricked her into seeing a doctor once when she was a kid and she was too traumatized to walk into a hospital.
Those scans found the growth that would eventually be confirmed as a recurrence. Despite knowing that was exactly what those scans meant, I told her I wasn’t worried about the growth.
Eventually the crisis of not joining the “27 Club” became too much for her. She told me she couldn’t be a good partner because of what she was experiencing—existential dread at not dying young—and that we needed to break up, but she still wanted to be friends. Not wanting to abandon someone I loved in their time of need, and also not wanting to lose someone I loved with another bout with cancer approaching, I agreed we should still be friends. We even went through with the planned date we had the weekend after she dumped me. It was the only time we ever had a picture taken together.
I think I would be happy with that friendship even now if it had lasted.
Instead, I reconnected with a prior ex, and my more recent ex went full no contact after saying she couldn’t deal with my self-destructive behavior. She blocked me on every platform we had ever communicated on after telling me she could not deal with me trying to be friends with another ex. It seems she believed you can only be friends with one ex at a time. I was devastated.
I did tell her that I wasn’t worried about the growth they found on my scans, but it was a lie that should have been obvious. I knew the cancer was back, everyone else around me knew the cancer was back, but it wouldn’t be entirely fair to say I got dumped because I had cancer, though I do believe it was part of it. I think she had an idea of what was to come and was looking for any excuse to not be around, so she latched onto the first one she found.
I was not warned that it is unbelievably difficult to get over a breakup when your body is being flooded with poison to kill the cancer. Our relationship only lasted three or four months, but I only now feel like I’m really moving on and it’s roughly eighteen months after we broke up. The cancer is gone again, and this time it seems that it will stay that way. She is also still gone. I still have those nagging thoughts about her. I wonder if she ended up moving like she had planned. I wonder if she is doing well. Most of all, I wonder if she has any idea what she really did to me. I have not yet made the move for my postgraduate studies, but I’m enrolled for this coming fall. I may be a cancer survivor and I got dumped while I had cancer, but I refuse to let either of those things define me. I intend to define myself, trauma be damned.
Leave a comment below. Remember to keep it positive!
The last piece of your post made me smile. I am glad you now have the strength to look forward to something that means growth and life for yourself (also, congrats on the long-lasting remission!). I similarly started a relationship with my best friend (25 years of friendship) six months before my cancer diagnosis. I was already sick and had cancer; we did not know yet and thought it was part of my autoimmune disease. He was a recovered addict with a long history of trauma and recovering from significant life changes. I had just finished grad school and got a good job, so I supported him in his transition. The summer was filled with concerts, hikes, dates, food, restaurants… I forgot I was that sick until I was admitted to the hospital. Cancer. He promised to be there every step of the way. He did for a month. He promised to marry me after chemo (my chances of remission were high) and left my house, my life, and myself alone in a hospital bed two weeks later. I found him trying to get my pain medications. He said I did not “respect his boundaries” and sent me the most horrible messages ever. It has been a year. I still struggle to trust and believe in the possibility of ever wanting to be around a person who could love me- now that I am so broken and my health continues to be loved scan after scan. Even when cancer recurrence is unlikely, that chemo aftermath left me with a lifestyle that I cannot bring myself yet to recognize. I don’t blame him for being unable to offer the love and commitment I would have been willing to offer: in sickness and health, in good and bad times. I got some lovely advice from my spiritual director: assuming he would enter that door right now, declaring he would love you forever, would you like to marry him? I could clearly see I was not willing to do so. The cancer had just revealed to me much of the wounds of that relationship (I take accountability for that) and the reality of his emotional unavailability to truly commit to a healthy relationship that entails sacrifice and proper choice: to decide to love when it is hard. I don’t think I will find that right now, and I’m not looking for it because I am still healing from my very fragile health and cancer trauma. But despite wishing him the best, I hope he finds the joy of loving with no attachments, without thinking that the joys and “love rush” define a relationship. I am grateful that cancer invited me to a deeper understanding of love and humility, fragility and compassion. And as complex as loneliness seems to be, it would have been much more challenging to be around people who would continue to hurt me, gaslight me, or attempt to make me be something or someone I cannot (because my health took that away from me, for now)I wish you all the best in your new journey. I genuinely wish you could see you deserve a love that embraces you entirely, without requiring you to do or be anything else or to “care” for anyone because we need care too. Thank you for sharing your heart honestly and authentically, vulnerability is something beautiful and courageous and that signals to me that you have healed enough, despite the pain that might still be there. I used to “befriend” or call my “exes” because I knew they already knew my story and I could save myself the trouble of being “known” from scratch by someone new. But these people also hold older versions of ourselves and have been emotionally unavailabke to us, wounded us, and are probably on their healing path too. Now I try to seek for other humans, who can see pain and death withouth running away from it, and that can value the deep insights, wisdom, love and beauty, that can result from deep and sustained human stuffering. Stay healthy and I wish you much love and joy in your grad school journey! I truly hope you find a community of people who admires the beauty you are offering here. God bless.